Legacy Vault Authentics – Authenticity Policy

Authenticity You Can Trust

Every signature. Every item. Verified and backed with confidence.

At Legacy Vault Authentics, authenticity is the foundation of everything we do. In a market where uncertainty is common, we are committed to providing collectors with items they can trust—without question.

Our Commitment to Authenticity

We do not deal in uncertainty. Every item we offer is carefully sourced, verified, and handled to the highest standards in the industry.

  • No guesswork
  • No shortcuts
  • No compromises

Only authentic, collectible pieces worthy of your trust.

How Our Items Are Verified

Every item is obtained through one or more of the following trusted methods:

  • Private Signings
    Conducted in controlled environments with direct or verified access to athletes
  • In-Person Signings
    Witnessed acquisitions from reputable events and trusted sources
  • Trusted Industry Partners
    Established relationships with proven, reliable suppliers
  • Private Collections
    We also acquire collections from individuals; however, every item undergoes a strict verification process before being offered for sale

Proof & Documentation

Whenever available, we provide:

  • Photo proof of the signing
  • Event details
  • Signing context

Transparency builds trust—and we prioritize both.

Zero-Tolerance for Inauthentic Items

We maintain a strict zero-tolerance policy for counterfeit or questionable memorabilia.

  • Any item that does not meet our standards is rejected
  • We do not resell or circulate questionable pieces

Our reputation is built on trust—and we protect it at all costs.

Lifetime Authenticity Guarantee

Every item sold by Legacy Vault Authentics is backed by our lifetime guarantee of authenticity.

If an item is ever proven to be inauthentic by PSA, Beckett, or JSA:

  1. Provide proof of determination
  2. Return the item to us

We will:

  • Issue a full refund
  • Cover return shipping costs

No exceptions.
Your confidence is our responsibility.

More Than a Signature

These aren’t just collectibles—they’re moments, memories, and pieces of history. We believe you deserve to own them with complete confidence.

Our Commitment to the Industry

Legacy Vault Authentics is committed to raising the standard in the memorabilia industry through trust, transparency, and uncompromising authenticity.